the 13th Story The13thStory.com / krg / Words / IRV To The Rescue




Highway 17 Music



IRV To The Rescue by Ken Goldstein

One of the biggest road blocks to third party organizing in the United States is our system of winner-takes-all elections. While many countries have forms of proportional representation, our government of single-member districts leads naturally to the dominance of only two major parties.

For many local, officially non-partisan, offices (such as city councils) the winner is required to receive 50% plus one vote; anything less leads to a costly run-off. For partisan offices, candidates who win a plurality with much less than 50% are said to lack a mandate, and have trouble claiming to represent their district. In either situation, many who voted for third party candidates are left wondering if their vote helped to elect the candidate they liked the least.

The solution to all of these problems may be available with IRV. IRV stands for Instant Run-off Voting. IRV systems allow for multiple candidates, while still guaranteeing that the winner will have at least 50% of the final vote, and that everybody's vote counts.

How IRV works is that rather than choosing a single candidate in a multiple candidate election, the voter selects their top three (or four, or whatever is allowed) and ranks them accordingly.

All the first-choice votes are tallied first. If no candidate manages to garner more than 50% of the vote, IRV eliminates the votes for the last place candidate and looks at the second choices on those ballots, adding them to the original totals. If there is still no clear winner, IRV does this again with each losing candidate, until one candidate hits the magic number for victory.

Of course, all this is done automatically on the first pass through the vote counting machines. No need for recounts, IRV guarantees a clear winner every time.

To illustrate how this might work, we'll use the following fictional example. In the race for the District 5 State Senator, Candidate A received 41% of the vote, Candidate B received 39%, and Candidate C got 20%. Today, that race would be given to Candidate A, even though more people didn't vote for him than did.

IRV, however, would look at the second choice votes for Candidate C's supporters. Maybe all of them liked Candidate B better than A, that would leave the final tally for Candidate A at 41% but make Candidate B the winner at 59%. Or, maybe they did prefer Candidate A. With IRV it will be clear that he or she should be the winner.

Because IRV guarantees that the winner is actually the candidate supported by the greatest number of people (whether as a first or second choice), it ensures that the winner can indeed claim a mandate to govern.

IRV also allows for more candidates to participate in an election without the "spoiler effect" coming into play. Rather than a third party harming the major party candidate it may be akin to, it allows for a deeper debate, and for voters to vote their conscience, without accidentally leading to their least-liked candidate winning.

Because more candidates can participate in the debate, and every voter's preferences are taken into consideration, more citizens are encouraged to vote. Greater voter participation has been the result wherever IRV has been implemented.

IRV also saves money by eliminating the need for the costly run-offs that are frequently required for local elections.

Word-wide, IRV has been used to elect Australia's Lower House, the Republic of Ireland's President, the mayor of London, and many other positions. In the United States, San Leandro and Oakland, California, have both passed city charter amendments instituting IRV in local elections. IRV is also gaining support in many other cities and counties across the nation.

If your local jurisdiction is debating whether or not to accept IRV, I urge you to support it. If they're not debating it, ask them why not. From city council to President, IRV could help bring choice, issue related debates, and new life to our democracy.

  • For more IRV information, check out the Center for Voting and Democracy's IRV page

This article originally appeared in slightly different form on Suite101.com .

All Contents © 2000-2003 by K.R. Goldstein. All rights reserved.